The Cast of Grey’s Anatomy: Who’s Dating Who?

Grey’s Anatomy first aired on ABC on March 27, 2005. The show revolves around the personal lives and career of Meredith Grey and the medical staff. The series was initially seen as just another regular American TV show, but as the episodes continued, everyone got hooked.

Source: Kathy Hutchins / Shutterstock.com

As fans of the TV series, we are equally as interested in their on-screen relationships as we are with the relationships of the actors in real life! So, who are the real-life partners of the amazing cast of Grey’s Anatomy?

Ellen Pompeo & Chris Ivery

Ellen Pompeo got her big break when she was cast in Grey’s Anatomy as Meredith Grey. She is now one of four original cast members left who haven’t been killed off of the show. Pompeo has also directed an episode of Grey’s Anatomy. Barely a few months before Pompeo made her debut in Grey’s Anatomy, she featured in an episode of Friends where she played the character of Missy Goldberg.

photo by s_bukley / Shutterstock.com

In 2003, Pompeo met her now-husband Chris Ivery, who is a music producer, while she was shopping at a grocery store in Los Angeles. The two of them began dating 6 months after their first meeting. Ellen Pompeo and Chris Ivery got married in 2007, and they now have three children together.

Patrick Dempsey & Jillian Fink

Patrick Dempsey played the role of Derek “McDreamy” Shepherd and was the hospital’s most charming neurosurgeon. Patrick’s character was married to Meredith Grey on the show, and they had one adopted daughter and one biological son. His fans were shocked when he left the TV series in 2015, but Dempsey was happy to leave before the fans got sick of him and this way he is able to spend more time with his family. The following year, he featured in Bridget Jones’s Baby.

Source: theknotnews.com

The actor married makeup artist and hairstylist Jillian Fink in 1999, and they have three children together. In January 2015, Patrick and Jillian announced their plans to divorce. However, after a brief split up, they called off their divorce in November of 2016.

Sara Ramirez & Ryan DeBolt

Sara Ramirez made her first appearance in the second season of Grey’s Anatomy, where she played the role of the well-loved Dr. Callie Torres.  Callie Torres was an orthopedic surgery resident. Like many of the medical drama’s stars, Sara Ramirez’s role as Callie brought her into the limelight. At the end of her time on the show in season 12, her character took her daughter and moved to New York.

Source: heightline.com

Sara Ramirez got married to banker Ryan DeBolt on July 4th, 2012 in a private beachside ceremony in New York. However, Sara shocked everyone when she revealed that she was bisexual in 2016. Despite that, there’s been no indication of controversy between the couple. She wrote that her decision to come out was a “very organic and natural” one.

Camilla Luddington & Matthew Alan

Camilla Luddington played the character Jo Wilson, a surgical resident, in the show. Camilla’s on screen husband is Alex Karev, one of the original cast members.  She made her debut into the show during the 9th season with a spot on American accent. The British beauty also played Kate Middleton in Lifetime’s movie William & Kate which depicts their love story.

Source: Kathy Hutchins / Shutterstock.com

Camilla is currently engaged to 13 Reasons Why actor Matthew Alan, who also guest-starred in an episode of Grey’s Anatomy. Camilla and Matthew announced their first child and daughter Hayden, in April 2007, although her birthday is unspecified.  They announced their engagement in January 2018, the same year that Camilla became an American citizen.  Camilla and Matthew got married in August 2019.

Jessica Capshaw & Christopher Gavigan

Jessica Capshaw played the role of Arizona Robbins, making her first appearance in the 5th season in 2009 as a surgical fellow in the pediatric surgery department. Her character was quickly promoted to the head of the department after the head of pediatric surgery was killed off of the show. Her character left the show by moving to New York with Callie and her daughter, and the producers claimed she was let go for creative reasons. Jessica’s actress mom Kate Capshaw is currently married to Steven Spielberg.

Picture: Paul Smith / Featureflash

Jessica Capshaw got married to Christopher Gavigan in May 2004 at her family’s East Hampton estate. They have 4 children together, named Luke, Poppy, Eve and Josephine. Her husband is one of the co-founders of The Honest Company, alongside Jessica Alba.

Kevin McKidd and Arielle Goldrath

Scottish actor Kevin McKidd came into the show during the 5th season and played Dr. Owen Hunt. Though known for his occasionally unorthodox methods, Dr. Hunt is said to be one of the hospital’s most talented surgeons. In the show, he treats a boy with Kawasaki disease, which a fan watching felt seemed very familiar and that episode ended up saving a boy’s life in real life.

Source: hellopinecone / People.com

Kevin McKidd has two children with his ex-wife Jane Parker. Before their divorce, his whole family became U.S. citizens.  However, in March 2018, he got married to Chef Arielle Goldrath in a private Jewish ceremony while they were expecting their first child.  They welcomed their son in May 2018, and later welcomed their daughter Nava in July 2019.

Sarah Drew & Peter Lanfer

Sarah Drew joined the show during the sixth season, playing the role of April Kepner – an attending trauma surgeon at the hospital. April is portrayed as a non-social religious Christian, who often prays for her patients before they start any surgical operation. Similar to her character in the TV series, Sarah Drew is a devoted Christian and is the daughter and sister of a pastor.

Source: Kathy Hutchins / Shutterstock.com

Sarah Drew is married to UCLA professor Peter Lanfer. The couple started dating before Drew started her acting career and now have 2 children together. She revealed in an interview that her husband traditionally wooed her with a love letter.  While pregnant in real life, she shot a scene for April’s labor on the show. She went home after work only to find she was in labor for real.

Caterina Scorsone & Rob Giles

Caterina Scorsone played the role of Derek Shepherd’s kid sister, Amelia Shepherd on the show. Amelia later followed the footsteps of her big brother and became a neurosurgeon. Her character has become very popular and is dating Atticus Lincoln, known as Link, who is new to the show.  At the beginning of this season, we found out that Amelia is pregnant.

Source: instagram.com

Caterina has been married to her actor and rockstar husband Rob Giles since 2009, and he is a member of the favorite rock band, Rescues. They currently have two children together. Just like in Grey’s Anatomy’s plotline, Caterina is pregnant at the same time that her character is.  The couple announced around Halloween this year that they are expecting their third child.

T.R Knight & Patrick Leahy

T.R Knight played Dr. George O’Malley and initially started off as an intern in the first season of the show. Knight, however, opted out from his $14 million contracts, leaving the show in 2009. He made a statement to CNN around the time he left the show, stating “My five-year experience proved to me that I could not trust any answer that was given, and with respect, I’m going to leave it at that.”

Source: gloriousa.com

Knight’s departure from the show was stirred when his costar Isaiah Washington allegedly called him a faggot. Since he left the show, he has worked on Broadway and appeared in shows like “The Good Wife” and “The Catch”. In 2013, T.R Knight got married to his partner of 3 years, ballet dancer and writer Patrick Leahy. The couple met at a dinner party in New York which was thrown by mutual friends. Shortly after this when Knight got the job on Broadway, he used it as the perfect excuse to move closer to his partner.

Katherine Heigl & Josh Kelley

Katherine Heigl is one of the original stars of Grey’s Anatomy and played Izzie Stevens. She was one of the surgical interns from the 1st season of the show. Izzie is a fan favorite and her relationship with a dying patient, Denny Duquette Jr., was the highlight of the 2nd season. In 2008, Heigl was nominated for an Emmy but turned it down stating she felt the writers didn’t give her the material this season to warrant an Emmy nomination and mentioned it should go to someone more deserving.

Source: Instagram.com

After 5 years of being on the show, Katherine left, leaving her fans devastated. According to Katherine, she took a break to focus on building a home with her husband, Josh Kelley. Katherine and her musician husband got married in 2007, and they have three children together. Heigl also has an adopted sibling and always knew she wanted to adopt children first. She adopted two daughters and had a son, who they ended up naming Joshua Jr.

Chyler Leigh & Nathan West

Chyler Leigh played the role of Lexie Grey, Meredith’s half-sister, and started her internship in the 3rd season of the show. Chyler had appeared in several movies and TV shows before joining the cast of Grey’s Anatomy, which she eventually left in 2012. She was killed off the show in a plane crash scene where she was sitting with the man she loved talking about the rest of their lives together.

Source: DFree / Shutterstock.com

Chyler is best known for her role as Janey Briggs in Not Another Teen Movie. She first met actor Nathan West at an audition for a WB series, Saving Graces. Besides for acting in the popular shows 7th Heaven or Bones, West is also known for playing Mike in season six of Grey’s Anatomy. Leigh and West got married in Alaska in 2002 and have three adorable children together.

James Pickens Jr. & Gina Taylor-Pickens

James Pickens Jr. played the character, Dr. Richard Webber. His character was also the former Chief of Surgery, at Grey Sloan Memorial Hospital. He had a lot of bad things happen to him throughout the years on this show, but he is now a surgeon married to the woman who owns the hospital instead of running it. He also has a daughter he more recently found out about. Aside from appearing in Grey’s Anatomy, he is also known for his role in the fiction series The X-Files.

Source: pinterest.com

Pickens Jr. has been married to his wife Gina Taylor-Pickens since 1984, and they are still happily married. Gina Taylor was a member of Musique. The couple have two children together, Carl Tharps and Gavyn Picken. They are now both pursuing careers in show biz.

Jesse Williams & Aryn Drake-Lee

Jesse Williams portrayed Jackson Avery – the Head of Plastic Surgery and attending ENT at Grey Sloan Memorial Hospital. His character was also one of the staff who joined from Mercy West Medical Center after the merger. Jackson is now one of the more well-known characters on the show and is currently dating one of the firefighters from the Grey’s spin-off show, ‘Station 19’.

Source: extratv.com

Jesse Williams is also a director, teacher, and activist. Williams married longtime partner Aryn Drake-Lee in 2012. They are blessed with two children – Sadie and Maceo. After fourteen and a half years together, they are going through a messy divorce.  Aryn is taking her experience and plans to use it as a form of therapy for mothers in her new podcast.

Loretta Devine & Glenn Marshall

Loretta Devine played the role of Adele Webber, Dr. Richard Webber’s wife in the drama series. Loretta is known for having a sweet, nurturing voice. Her character in the show went through a lot. She lost her pregnancy in a very dramatic episode, had Alzheimers and later died of a heart attack after surgery. In 2011 she won a Primetime Emmy Award for Outstanding Guest Actress in a Drama Series for her performance in Grey’s Anatomy.

Glenn Marshall and Loretta Devine
Photo by Broadimage/Shutterstock

Loretta is married to Glenn Marshall, an accountant. The couple is happily married and occasionally are seen attending an event together that she has been invited to. There was also a mix up that she was previously married to someone named Lamar Tyler, who she had a son with. Loretta Devine has however denied the rumor.

Katherine Burton & Michael Ritchie

Kate Burton is well-known for her role as Ellie Grey in the drama series. She appeared in 19 episodes and played the part of a brilliant surgeon with a Harper Avery Award, but a difficult mother to her daughter, Meredith Grey. In season 14, Meredith has a dream that her mother is clapping for her after she wins her own Harper Avery Award.

Source: alchetron.com

Kate is a British citizen and has kept her citizenship there after her family moved to Manhattan, but she considers herself to be an American actress. Kate Burton is married to Michael Ritchie, and they share 2 children. The couple first met at the Square Theatre in New York in 1982, and they proceeded to get married 3 years later. The couple now lives together in Los Feliz along with their dog, Phil, who is a Labrador mix.

Brooke Smith & Steven Lubensky

Brooke Smith played the role of outspoken Dr. Erica Hahn in Grey’s Anatomy. However, she was abruptly fired from the TV series in 2008. There were speculations that she was let go because of her lesbian role with Torres. Rhimes responded to her claims stating “[she] just didn’t see the magic and chemistry between Callie and Erica and that’s why the story did not continue and Erica was no more.” Afterward, she brought in Arizona Robbins as Callie’s new love interest.

Source: Instagram

Beyond the screen, Brooke Smith has been married to cinematographer Steve Lubensky since January 6, 1999.  They have two children together, Fanny Grace who was born in 2003, and Lucy who was adopted from Ethiopia. They currently live together in the Upper West Side New York and Beachwood Canyon, LA.

Debbie Allen & Norm Nixon

Debbie Allen joined the cast of ABC’s drama series during the 8th season to play the character, Catherine Fox. She also directed a couple of episodes, eventually becoming an executive producer during season 12 of the show. Her character is now married to Richard Weber, and she owns Grey Sloan Memorial Hospital. Her on-camera son is Jackson Avery.

Source: zimbio.com

Debbie Allen is married to retired basketball player Norm Nixon. Before they got married, the couple appeared in The Fish That Saved Pittsburgh in 1979. They have been married since 1984, recently celebrating their 35th wedding anniversary. The couple have 2 children together, Normal Ellard JR. and Vivian Nicole, and a son from Nixon’s previous marriage, DeVaughn. Debbie says that her marriage and her children are her more valuable achievements.

Kim Raver & Manuel Boyer

Kim Raver portrayed the character of Dr. Teddy Altman – an attending cardiothoracic surgeon at the fictional health institution – in ABC’s medical drama series. Raver played this character from season 6 to 8 and reprised her role in season 14. In her role, she is currently dating Owen Hunt and just gave birth to a baby girl, Allison.

Source: zimbio.com

Kim Raver is married to Manuel Boyer, who is a French art director. The couple met at a swimming pool in New York City and has been married since 2000. They now have 2 children together named Luke West and Leo Kipling. A fun fact you might not remember about Kim is that she started her career at age six appearing in Sesame Street.

Sandra Oh & Andrew Featherston

Sandra Oh is popularly known for her role as Dr. Cristina Yang. In the series, she had a relationship with Preston Burke. The lovers both suffered a miscarriage just before Burke leaves her at the altar. She took her honeymoon with Meredith Grey and came back to find out that Burke has moved away. She continued to be Grey’s sidekick until she left the show in 2014.

Source: knowcelebs.com

Sandra Oh’s personal life hits a couple of highs and lows. She divorced her first husband, filmmaker Alexander Payne, in 2006 before she fell in love once with Andrew Featherston. Featherstone is the percussionist in the indie band The Hereafter. The happy couple started dating in 2007 and are still going strong till today.

Chandra Wilson & John Doe

We know Chandra Wilson as popular Miranda Bailey on the series. On the show, her relationship is one of the few dramatic ones. Although her marriage to Ben Warren comes with a series of ups and downs, it’s definitely a perfect example of a solid union in Grey’s Anatomy! Chandra shows up on two other spin-offs from Grey’s Anatomy, Private Practice and Station 19. Her on-screen husband Ben Warren is one of the main characters in the show Station 19.

Chandra Wilson
Source: Liverampup

While Station 19 is a spin-off of Grey’s Anatomy, it was only produced by Shondaland and was created by Stacy McKee. The firefighters end up a lot at Grey Sloan Memorial throughout the series, getting a glimpse of what goes on during that week of Grey’s Anatomy.
Away from the series, Wilson does not like her private life in the open. Till today, no one knows the name of her lover whom she presently has 3 kids with Serena, Joy, and Michael.

Justin Chambers & Keisha Chambers

Justin Chambers, one of Grey’s Anatomy longest-lasting characters, played the role of Alex Karev. Chamber’s character was actually added in later after they shot the first episode, and now he is one of the four original characters who are still alive on the show today. His character survived being fired from the shows hospital, and even got a new job at a rival hospital.

Justin Chambers and wife Keisha arriving at The Victoria's Secret Fashion Show
Justin Chambers and wife Keisha arriving at The Victoria’s Secret Fashion Show at Kodak Theatre on November 16, 2006, in Hollywood, CA. Photo by s_bukley / Shutterstock

Unlike his character in the TV series, Justin has maintained a steady relationship with his wife, Keisha Chambers since 1993, with whom he has 5 adorable children!  The couple first met in 1992 while Justin was working as a model for Calvin Klein Ad company where Keisha was working as a model agency booker. A year later, they tied the nuptial knot secretly.

Martin Henderson & Helen Randag

Martin Henderson is loved by fans of the medical drama for his role as Dr. Nathan Riggs in Grey’s. He wasn’t so loved at first, on-screen, by Owen Hunt. He and Owen went back to when they were in the army. Riggs was dating Owen’s sister, Megan, who at the time they thought was dead. Before he left the show, Owen’s sister was found, kidnapped but alive. She was brought back and the two moved to Malibu to be with her son.

Source: nzherald.co.nz

Martin Henderson is an actor from New Zealand and is usually known for keeping his personal life private. However, he couldn’t hide his romantic relationship with popular director and producer, Helen Randag. He made his relationship official via Instagram when he posted a photo of himself and Helen with the caption: “Out with my bae – I love you, darling.” Randag quickly replied with her post saying “I love you too my darling.”

Eric Dane & Rebecca Gayheart

Eric Dane was loved by female fans as he played the role of the handsome, womanizing Doctor ‘McSteamy’ Mark Sloan. While Sloan was known for being with a lot of women in the show, he was just getting into something with Lexie Grey before she passed away in the plane crash. Unfortunately, Sloan also died from injuries from that crash. His character had such a great impact on the show that Seattle Grace was re-named Grey-Sloan Memorial Hospital in memory of him after his tragic departure.

Source: eonline.com

Off the screen, Dane got married to American model Rebecca Gayheart in 2004. The couple has two daughters, Billie Beatrice and Georgia Geraldine Dane. They had a fair share of trying times as well, especially in 2009 when a nude video of him, his wife and Kari Ann Peniche.

Kate Walsh & Alex Young

Kate Walsh played Dr. Addison Montgomery on Greys Anatomy for only 2 seasons and ended season one as Derek’s ex-wife. While she came into the show a bit colder feeling, she ended up being so loved that Shonda Rhimes created a show called Private Practice which followed her transferring to a California clinic.

Source: dailymail.co.uk

Let’s take a look at Kate Walsh’s love life off-screen. Well, she married Alex Young in 2007 and ended up divorcing three years later. She had always thought that she would be married with three or four kids. In her words, “I always knew I wanted to be an actress, but I think I always wanted a quote-unquote normal life.” Since her divorce, she dated Trevor Davis, but they broke up in 2016. In 2015, she was diagnosed with a benign meningioma and had to have surgery. She took nine months off to recover from this.

Isaiah Washington & Jenisa Garland

Washington is well known amongst Grey’s Anatomy fans, but before the actor’s shocking departure from the series, he was known for playing the role of the handsome surgeon Dr. Preston Burke. He had an on and off relationship with Christina Yang during the series, and he later left her at the altar. Rhimes called Washington up to let him know that he would not be returning to the show after it was rumored there was some controversy between him and T.R. Knight.

Source: Shutterstock

Isaiah Washington is married to Jenisa Garland. The couple got married in 1996, and they have three children together: Isaiah Akin, Thyme, and Iman. You can read more about him in his book called A Man from Another Land, which details his life and his film career.

Jason Winston George & Vandana Khanna

Jason Winston George has been playing Dr. Ben Warren since season 6 of Grey’s Anatomy. He starts out as an anesthesiologist, eventually going to become a doctor and in the end changing his mind again to become a firefighter/EMT. His character was so popular that Jason was given another role of the Grey’s Anatomy spin-off, a series titled Station 19 where he joins a team of firefighters. Dr. Ben Warren married Miranda Bailey on the series and recently found out his on-screen wife is pregnant.

Source: screenertv.com

In real life, Jason is happily married to Vandana Khanna. Khanna is an Indian-American poet and author, and they met at the University of Virginia. The couple got married in 1999 and have three children together, Jasmine and twins Arun and Nikhil.

Giacomo Gianniotti & Nichole Gustafson

Handsome Italian-Canadian actor Giacomo Gianniotti plays Dr. Andrew DeLuca in Grey’s Anatomy. He started out as the brother of one of the doctors coming to intern at the hospital. DeLuca more recently told Meredith Grey he is in love with her, and the two of them have been getting into trouble on the show. They helped cover up insurance fraud and DeLuca was initially arrested for it before Meredith Grey turned herself in.

Giacomo Gianniotti & Nichole Gustafson
Source: Entertainment tonight

Away from the screens, Giacomo has a pretty cool love life. He spent the early parts of his life the great city Rome before moving to Toronto where his acting career started. He recently announced his engagement to Nichole Gustafson, a makeup artist, in November 2017. The couple got married in Italy in April of 2019.

Taye Diggs and Amanza Smith

You are right, Taye Diggs isn’t really from Grey’s Anatomy. Taye Diggs was popularly known by fans for his role as Dr. Sam Bennett in Private Practice. He guest-starred on the Grey’s Anatomy/ Private Practice Crossover Event where Grey’s Anatomy fans loved him.

Source: whosdatedwho.com

He graduated from Syracuse University with a Bachelor’s Degree of Art in musical theatre. Diggs was married to Idina Menzel who he met on the set of musical rent. They had a son named Walker Nathaniel Diggs who was born in 2009. The couple is presently divorced. Taye has since moved on and has been dating his new girlfriend, Amanza Smith Brown, since 2014. He has made a couple of red carpet appearances with her in the summer.

Marika Domińczyk and Scott Folly

You might know her from The 40-Year-Old Virgin or Brothers & Sisters. Marika Dominczyk is a Polish-American actress who was popularly known for her role as Dr. Eliza Minnick in Grey’s Anatomy. Arizona Robins goes out on a date with her but that ends quickly once the staff starts to hate Eliza’s teaching methods. They continued to work to get her fired, and she was eventually fired from the hospital. This led to Domińczyk being released from the cast.

Source: usmagazine.com

Domińczyk was engaged to actor Scott Foley for a year before they got married in June 2007. The couple had a private wedding ceremony in Hawaii. They have three children, a girl and two boys named Malina, Keller Aleksander and Konrad.

Scott Elrod and Vanessa Vazart

Some people know him from Top Gun, but fans of Grey’s Anatomy know Scott Elrod as the army cancer surgeon and lovely Will Thorpe. He first met Meredith when Grey Sloan team helped him out with a surgery on his patient. Will had a romantic relationship with Meredith, but she was scared to start a relationship, as her husband Derek recently died.

Source: articlebio.com

Away from the screen, Scott got engaged to his long-term girlfriend Vanessa after she got pregnant. He shared this wonderful news on his Instagram page. The couple already has their wedding plans, but no date has been revealed yet. They have a son together, Easton Thomas Elrod, who was born on June 22, 2016, just after Father’s Day.

Leven Rambin and Tilky Jones

Leven Rambin played the role of Sloan Riley in the popular medical TV series. Sloan Riley is the long lost daughter of Mark Sloan. She is partly the cause of the break up between her father Mark and Lexie. Leven was active in the series for 5 seasons, but wasn’t a weekly regular.

Source: dailymail.co.uk

In real life, Rambin has not had an easy ride with her relationships. First Leven was engaged to Geoffrey James Clark, and that didn’t work out. Then she was married to actor Jim Parrack, but they divorced after 2 years of marriage. Later on Rambin revealed that Parrack cheated on her. Hence, divorce. Presently, Rambin is in a relationship with actor Tilky Jones.
Next we have someone who also wasn’t around for too long, but was pretty memorable.

Charles Michael Davis and Nida

Charles Michael Davis, previously known for appearing on That’s So Raven and Chicago P.D., played Jason Myers in season 9 of Grey’s Anatomy. Jason Myers is an obstetrics and gynecology resident at Grey Sloan Memorial Hospital. There was a time he dated Jo Wilson in the show, but he didn’t last too long with the show.

Source: heightline.com

Charles has never been married but he once dated popular photographer and model, Katrina Amato. They parted ways in September 2014 after Charles made a statement on the radio that he was single. He then dated Monika Anne Clarke for a while, an American model. He is currently engaged to another Pakistani model Nida. Not much is known about their relationship, but in October 2018, we heard they got engaged.

Christina Ricci and James Heerdegen

Christina Ricci played the role of Hannah Davies in season two of Grey’s Anatomy. Hanna was the girl whose hand was on a live bomb inside a person. These were regular occurrences at the Grey Sloan Memorial Hospital, and the doctors do their best to find solutions.

Source: eonline.com

Christina Ricci dated Owen Benjamin in 2008, and got engaged in 2009. This relationship didn’t last too long, and they ended up terminating the engagement only two months later. Ricci is now married to James Heerdegen. The duo first met on set while working on the series Pan Am in 2012. They ended up getting married in Manhattan in October of 2013. They have a lovely son by the name Freddie who was born in August 2014.

Chris O’Donnell and Caroline Fentress

Chris O’Donnell played Dr. Finn Dandridge just season 2 and 3 of Grey’s Anatomy. Finn Dandridge got a nickname kind of like McDreamy and McSteamy. His nickname was McVet. He went out on a few dates with Meredith, the first woman he went out with since his wife passed in-show, and competed for Meredith’s love with Derek Shepard. However, he eventually loses her to Derek Shepard. Nothing can stand between Meredith and Derek’s love in this show.

Source: zimbio.com

Back in 1993, Chris briefly went out with Reese Witherspoon. Chris is now married to Caroline Fentress who a graduate of Rollins and currently works as a school teacher. The couple, who were married in 1997 have 5 children together. Presently, O’Donnell is a practicing Roman Catholic. O’Donnell’s brother, John, founded the clothing.